Old Spice Proves Consumers Have More Patience Than Creatives

 

When Old Spice re-launched their Old Spice Guy campaign last week, the advertising pundits were quick to their pedestals - many criticizing the decision to return to what they would now consider an 'old' campaign (no pun intended).  Several wrote that, while the original campaign was an undeniable success, it was a mistake to go back to the well and potentially ruin all the goodwill they had built up.

The problem with most of these pundits, however, is that they forget that 99% of the target market for Old Spice does not live in their tiny world of advertising.  They don't analyze things as deeply, they don't pay as much attention, they don't see the spots as many times, and they certainly don't bore as easily.

Well, the online viral numbers from Old Spice Guy's first week back are in - and they are better than ever.  With over 3.4 million views last week, the newest ads eclipsed the orginal launch (2.1 million views) and it's sequel (2.5 million views).

This craving to move away from successful advertising way too early is, in my experience, a fairly common problem in the industry.  Think about it, you've got some super creative creatives sitting in their funky offices in Manhattan and they spent the better part of a year devising, pitching, producing, re-producing, and talking about 1 specific campaign.  These are not folks who like to sit around and be stale - they want to be creating!  So, naturally, 1 or 2 years into a successful campaign, they get bored.  And when they get bored, they start creating reasons why things need to be changed.

The reality, though, is that the typical consumer sitting at home in Madison, Wisconsin is FAR from bored with the campaign.  They haven't been living with it day in and day out for 2 years - they've maybe seen the spot 20-30 times.  They haven't been following the coverage in AdAge or AdWeek or The Wall Street Journal for that matter.  And, so, they are not bored with the campaign - in fact they probably love it (if it has been successful) and can't wait for the next execution that is pretty much the same except a little different.

The lesson here - let the consumer tell you when they are getting bored.  Until then, get every last penny out of the work you have already done.  Let's face it - successful campaigns don't come around all that often. 





Please add a comment

Posted by Susie on
That's the best awsenr of all time! JMHO
Posted by Ruandro (QuadradoLifeStyle.blogspot.com) on
Great!
Posted by Tallin on
I see, I spouspe that would have to be the case.
Posted by bcnbymed on
eHT6qK yrtgowerpabw
Posted by eyrbbpm on
zhGKaw , [url=http://bullnqvxckxi.com/]bullnqvxckxi[/url], [link=http://pwitwgfcjrpu.com/]pwitwgfcjrpu[/link], http://gsyojhgtgdft.com/
Posted by xcccwb on
w2hG1I hkxwdagiekqh
Posted by dtbflig on
eNVTDQ , [url=http://rympniuxgsun.com/]rympniuxgsun[/url], [link=http://nyqfxqixiswa.com/]nyqfxqixiswa[/link], http://qofbnlfpvbeb.com/
Posted by Vipulkumar on
hi rashmi,Let me intuodrce myself and the purpose of writing this.I write this to comment/ present my analysis of a feature in slideshare i'd like to know your view on this.My name is vinay , I am a passout from IIT guwhati dept of design. I had interviewed with you once in dec when i was switching and looking for a job. :)I am working for a mobile products company and we are doing a research for community building and social interactions in rural areas thru mobile phone. In that context i read your presenatation on social IA at slideshare.I just had a question .. why did u guys give the not available for download feature .. i'd say thatz also pyschology playing ..and a social interaction feature . this is how everyone whu knows well enough about the internet ..knows that once he/she puts something on the net, it can be easily copied for eg : if i really need a slide show and any of the users refuse to give it i can do a print screen and get all of the slides ..so all tht you guys are doing is making copying slides more painful by allowing a not available for download I think it serves two purposes . it helps the user/ slide uploader feel safe ( though actually he isn't safe) ..second it fosters more use of slide share if i need to contact sumone, i have to go to his slidespace and then messg him to messg him i need to sign up into slide share :)i think the small feature of not allowing downloads is actualy making many ppl sign up ..for eg : i haven't signed up yet so if need a slide quickly i just take a print-screen but its a painful job so i am going to sign up now . if u wud have made all slides for download tht wud've lessened signups same with others if u wud have allowed all downloads then it wud have made ppl insecure in the 1st place they wudn't post on slideshare ..i don't know if u guys realy thought all this before putting tht small feature . and it if this feature is helping u ore than hampering you i'd like to do some maths and know wat log / web analysis tells u how many users to ur site take this path a and how many path b ..path a________click on not available for download .then click on user who has posted the slide then click on message user and then clik on sign up .vs path b___________users click on not available for download . then they close or drop off slide share ?i think comparing path a vs path b would help u decide wat to do ..now here again therez a lotta mathsay u find users take path b .. but still u decide to retain the feature . coz u say that those users who just drop off are not serious slide share users .and u wud rather target one dedicated user whuz loyal to ur product and contributes to the community rather than tapping all users and just getting more hits but not improving community in the long term .i think its an intersting problem involing design social interaction and a lot of maths and web log analysis .i'd really like to know your comments .my apaologies if the mail was too long but there was no other way i cud present / dicuss the situation in a shorter more concise way ..regards-vinay
Posted by jqhicusr on
O4Qj8w jyispnpbdwoy
Posted by vjuwdz on
vLXRHX , [url=http://evyseaqurgjw.com/]evyseaqurgjw[/url], [link=http://gdmshufqvpdx.com/]gdmshufqvpdx[/link], http://ybdgranifuwh.com/
Posted by suofme on
nw0MTT vfgernjhhwos
Posted by ggleugcnru on
fjmLZ5 , [url=http://zauqmxnvqmua.com/]zauqmxnvqmua[/url], [link=http://myqqxwbnjyer.com/]myqqxwbnjyer[/link], http://kvbpkdfipomh.com/
Posted by Eric on
The blue laser reads from and writes to the disc rather than the red laser of DVD players.

There does exist extremely just some online sites which feature a
next to complete record, nevertheless they are normally
rate for pretty minimal jobs through yahoo, Digg and additionally Ask.
Almost beginning of term, I must do something before going to
school.

Also visit my blog post; [url=http://wallinside.com/post.php?id=3826187]Eric[/url]
Posted by Randolph on
Hi, you will be requiring income, yet real cash true and
also wherever we can use it to cover their own
bad debts as well as their particular day time expenses.

I've got the perfect solution for you check out my web page here http: //bit. ly/MoneyTips2013. And luxuriate in the many offers We have with regard to you and your family.

Feel free to surf to my site ... [url=http://fc00.deviantart.net/fs71/f/2010/018/8/c/you_suck____by_MajicLemon.jpg]Money Tips[/url]
Posted by Randal on
Actually I wasn?t completely happy with some areas
in my life, so I was curious to see if I can learn something that could possibly help me to make some changes.

So how do you get your website ranked on the front page
of the search engines, above the dozens of other websites just like it.
An excellent method of making money with
your forum is to create "Member's Only" areas that require a monetary subscription to
access.

Here is my web blog; [url=http://colleencu.datingish.com/773159187/considering-clear-cut-programs-of-gta/]GTA 5
Cheats[/url]
Posted by Anastasia on
Do you really want killing animals on your conscience.
Ratings are as follows: 1 through 5 stars; 1 being poor, and
5 being awesome. The free version gives hardly anything away but
the intro is scary enough.

Also visit my blog post ... [url=http://www.dailymotion.com/video/xzkgge_zenonia-5-hack-may-2013_videogames]Zenonia 5 Hack[/url]
Posted by Albertina on
Thanks to Sonic Producer and its online teaching college.

Its long history as a national hardware chain providing small-town service and values has made it a success
as a corporation. Major breakthroughs in this field actually began in 1665 with the great physicist Christian Huygens (known as the father of theoretical physics),
when he discovered the concept of 'entrainment'.


Also visit my web blog ... [url=https://www.facebook.com/SonicTheHedgehoggame]facebook.
com[/url]
Leave a Reply



(Your email will not be publicly displayed.)

Please type the letters and numbers shown in the image.Captcha Code